Reflections Craft
Sign In

· 9 min read

How to Spot a Fake Diamond: What Works and What Doesn't

How to spot a fake diamond, from a jeweller: why the fog and newspaper tests fail, what moissanite doubling looks like, and how to verify a lab report.

Most of the popular tests for spotting a fake diamond don't work. The fog test, the newspaper test and the "does it scratch glass" test all fail at home. A few things are worth checking: whether the stone's back facets look doubled, whether it shows rainbow fire far stronger than a diamond's, and whether its grading report and girdle inscription match. GIA itself says there is no reliable at-home test, and that the dependable answer comes from a trained gemologist or an independent laboratory.

This guide covers what each home test can and can't tell you, what the common fakes actually are, and the checks that hold up when real money is at stake.

First, decide what "fake" means

People who ask this are usually worried about one of three things, and the answer changes depending on which.

  • A simulant passed off as diamond. This is a different material that only looks like diamond: cubic zirconia (CZ), synthetic moissanite or glass. GIA describes simulants as "completely unrelated to diamonds at the atomic level" on its simulants, moissanite and lab-grown diamonds page.
  • A lab-grown diamond sold as natural. A lab-grown diamond is not a fake. It is real diamond. GIA says lab-grown diamonds "have the same crystal structure, consisting of tightly bonded carbon atoms" and "nearly the same chemical, optical and physical properties as natural diamonds." The problem is disclosure, not identity.
  • A real diamond with a false report. The stone is diamond, but the colour, clarity or weight on the paperwork belongs to a better stone.

The US Federal Trade Commission's Jewelry Guides set out the legal definition. 16 CFR § 23.12 defines a diamond as "a mineral consisting essentially of pure carbon crystallized in the isometric system," and says "its hardness is 10; its specific gravity is approximately 3.52; and it has a refractive index of 2.42." The same section lets sellers call a laboratory-created stone a diamond only with a clear and conspicuous disclosure, such as "laboratory-grown," that it was not mined. Canadian sellers follow their own rules, but the distinction is the same: a simulant is a different material, and a lab-grown diamond is diamond with a different origin.

The home tests, and why most of them fail

In its article on how to tell if a diamond is real, GIA goes through the usual internet tests one by one. Here is what it found, with my notes from the bench.

The fog test

The idea is that you breathe on the stone and a real diamond clears straight away. GIA's verdict: "This test cannot be replicated with consistent results." Nobody tells you how long to breathe or how much of the surface needs to fog, and room humidity changes the result. Natural and lab-grown diamonds also behave the same way, so even a "pass" tells you nothing about origin.

The newspaper or read-through test

You put the stone table-down on printed text, and supposedly you can't read through a diamond. GIA calls it "another problematic test" that "can be very confusing and misleading for the inexperienced." The result depends heavily on cut. A shallow, poorly cut diamond can leak light and let print show through.

The scratch or sandpaper test

Diamond is hardness 10, so people rub it on sandpaper or glass. GIA's warning is blunt: it is "a destructive test and should never be used!" The grit can damage the stone and "diminish its value." Diamond is hard but brittle along certain directions, and you can chip a real one this way.

Sparkle, sharp edges and the metal

  • Sparkle: "Almost any faceted gem like synthetic moissanite... will sparkle," GIA notes. Moissanite out-sparkles diamond for rainbow colour.
  • Sharp facet edges: GIA points out that natural and synthetic diamonds both have sharp edges, and any gem can show worn facet junctions.
  • The setting: A gold or platinum mount suggests someone thought the stone was worth it. GIA says "the metal alone is not a definitive clue." Real diamonds get set in silver, and CZ gets set in 14k gold.

The loupe

The myth is that real diamonds have inclusions and fakes are perfect. GIA says consumers find loupes hard to use and that "some diamonds are flawless and you will see no inclusions." Plenty of lab-grown diamonds are very clean too. A loupe does help with one thing, though, which is covered next.

What a 10x loupe can actually show you

The loupe won't prove a diamond, but in patient hands it can catch the most common convincing simulant. GIA's introduction to imitation diamonds says moissanite "is doubly refractive, so viewers will see a double image of its back facets," and that it "has more than twice the fire of diamond and slightly more brilliance."

Here is how to look:

  1. Clean the stone first. Skin oil blurs everything.
  2. Hold the loupe against your eye and bring the stone up to it, not the other way round.
  3. Look through the stone at an angle, past the table facet, rather than straight down. Moissanite is often cut to hide its doubling when viewed straight through the top.
  4. Focus on the facet edges on the far side of the stone. If each edge looks like two close parallel lines, like a slightly out-of-register print, that is double refraction. Diamond is singly refractive and shows crisp single lines.
  5. Then move the stone under a single light source, like a phone torch, and watch the colour flashes. A stone that throws heavy rainbow fire, especially at 1 carat and up, deserves a closer look.

Two cautions. First, doubling is easier to see in larger stones and can be very hard to see in small ones. Second, this only rules moissanite in or out. It says nothing about CZ, which is singly refractive, or about natural versus lab-grown.

CZ has its own tells. GIA notes that CZ has a hardness of 8.5, so after years of wear its facet edges tend to get scuffed and rounded in a way diamond's don't, and that "CZ will, however, yellow in color over time." An older ring with soft, worn facet edges and a slightly yellowed stone is worth taking in to be checked.

How the usual suspects compare

This table only uses properties published by GIA or the FTC. Where a source doesn't give a number, I've left it blank rather than guess.

MaterialWhat it isHardnessOptical tellSource
Natural diamondCarbon, isometric crystal10Singly refractive; RI 2.42; SG about 3.52FTC, 16 CFR § 23.12
Lab-grown diamondSame crystal structure as naturalSame as diamondCan't be separated by eye; needs lab testingGIA 4Cs
Synthetic moissaniteSimulant, different materialNot stated by sourceDoubled back facets, more than twice diamond's fire; SG 3.22GIA, GIA Gems & Gemology
Cubic zirconiaSimulant, zirconium oxide8.5Can yellow over time; edges wearGIA
GlassSimulantNot stated by sourceLacks diamond's brillianceGIA

The honest takeaway: the only line in this table you can check at your kitchen table is moissanite doubling. Everything else needs instruments.

Handheld testers: useful, but know their limits

Jewellers use electronic diamond testers every day, and they're good for quick screening. They aren't a final answer. Different testers measure different things, and some materials can confuse a particular model. A basic tester that says "diamond" may not have been designed to tell diamond from moissanite. None of the cheap units separates natural from lab-grown diamond. GIA's page on HPHT and CVD growth describes that separation as lab work, using fluorescence patterns, growth structure and purpose-built instruments such as the GIA iD100.

If a jeweller tests your stone, ask what the tester can and can't detect. If the stone is worth a significant amount and the answer is "it beeped," that isn't enough. Buying your own tester is rarely worth it. A single reading from someone who uses one daily and knows its blind spots is more useful.

Paperwork: the check that actually protects you

For a stone you're about to buy, the grading report matters more than any home test, as long as you verify it.

GIA's FAQ on report authenticity says that "all laboratory-grown diamonds assessed by GIA will have their girdles inscribed with their GIA report numbers," and that its lab-grown reports "are digital only. If it can be found on Report Check, the report is authentic."

An inscription alone doesn't prove anything, though. GIA's journal Gems & Gemology has documented simulants carrying forged inscriptions. In a Fall 2020 lab note, Hlatshwayo and Eaton-Magaña described a 1.02 ct synthetic moissanite inscribed with the report number of a real E-colour natural diamond of the same weight. The lab caught it through testing, an inscription font that didn't match GIA's, and "obvious double refraction." The authors called it "our first instance of a fraudulent inscription on a diamond simulant." A Fall 2022 lab note by Shoko Odake reported a 1.71 ct moissanite carrying another forged GIA inscription.

So the check has three parts:

  1. Look up the report number on the lab's own website, not through a link the seller sends you.
  2. Compare the measurements in millimetres and the carat weight on the report with the actual stone. The 2020 moissanite was exposed partly because its measurements didn't fit, since moissanite is lighter than diamond for the same size.
  3. Read the girdle inscription under magnification and check it matches the report number exactly.

A private sale with no report, or a report from a lab you can't verify online, means paying for an independent lab test before you hand over the money. On a stone worth a few thousand dollars, the test is cheap insurance.

What to do next

If you're checking a stone you already own, try the angled loupe check for doubling, then take it to a jeweller with a proper tester. If anything is unclear, or the stone matters to you, send it to an independent lab. Skip the fog, newspaper and sandpaper tests.

If you're buying, start from paperwork you can verify. Every stone in our loose diamond search comes with its grading report so you can look it up yourself before choosing a setting. For more on reading the report once you have it, see our other buying guides.

Sources

  • Gemological Institute of America (GIA), "How to Tell if a Diamond Is Real," GIA 4Cs blog. 4cs.gia.edu
  • Gemological Institute of America (GIA), "Simulants, Moissanite and Lab-Grown Diamonds," GIA 4Cs. 4cs.gia.edu
  • Gemological Institute of America (GIA), "An Introduction to Imitation Diamonds & Other Gems." gia.edu
  • Gemological Institute of America (GIA), "HPHT and CVD Diamond Growth Processes." gia.edu
  • Gemological Institute of America (GIA), "How can I be sure that my GIA Laboratory-Grown Diamond Report is authentic?" FAQ. gia.edu
  • Hlatshwayo and Eaton-Magaña, "Synthetic Moissanite with Fraudulent GIA Inscription," Gems & Gemology Lab Notes, Fall 2020. gia.edu
  • Shoko Odake, "Fraudulently Inscribed Synthetic Moissanite," Gems & Gemology Lab Notes, Fall 2022. gia.edu
  • US Federal Trade Commission, Guides for the Jewelry, Precious Metals, and Pewter Industries, 16 CFR § 23.12, "Definition and misuse of the word 'diamond'," via Cornell Legal Information Institute. law.cornell.edu